British Consuls in South Formosa

George Macdonald Home Playfair

The Takao Club

George Macdonald Home Playfair

 

 China Consular Service


      George Macdonald Home Playfair served twice in South Formosa. The first time, in the 1870s, when the Taiwan consulate at Taiwan-fu (Tainan) was in charge of the whole island of Formosa, covering the ports of Tamsui, Anping and Takow. The second time when the Taiwan Consulate covered only Taiwan-fu, Anping, Takow, and the southern part of Formosa. The northern part of Formosa was the responsibility of the Tamsui Consulate, where George Macdonald Home Playfair also served, as did his second cousin Frank William Walter Playfair of the Japan Consular Service.

      On his first appointment to Formosa, George Macdonald Home Playfair was stationed at Taiwan-fu [臺灣府] as Third Assistant at the British Consulate of the Island of Formosa from 14 November 1876 through 1877. In December 1876 George Playfair made a visit to the southernmost parts of Formosa in the company of the outgoing Acting Commissioner John McLeavy Brown of the Imperial Maritime Customs, and the incoming Acting Commissioner Thomas Francis Hughes. The party travelled down from Takow [打狗] aboard the Customs Revenue Cutter , the Ling-Feng [凌風], and first visited the new district capital of Heng-ch’un [恆春] about 6 miles inland which was under construction. For Playfair a major part of the reason for visiting the South was to dispel rumours in the Hongkong newspapers of unrest in that district; the rumours proved unfounded mainly because the new Chinese District Magistrate was paying the principal chief of the aborigines 72 silver dollars quarterly to maintain the peace. Playfair, McLeavy Brown and Hughes also the visited the promontory at Oluanpi [鵝鑾鼻] which had been leased from the aborigines the previous year by the Imperial Maritime Customs as the site for the planned South Cape Lighthouse. During 1877 Playfair served as Acting Consul from 21 February, when Acting Consul Thomas Watters departed to become Consul at Wuhu [蕪湖], to 18 April 1877, when Vice-Consul Alexander Frater arrived from Tamsui [淡水] to take charge.

      On his second appointment to Taiwan, First Assistant George Macdonald Home Playfair was stationed at Taiwan-fu as the Acting Consul of the Taiwan Consular District, or South Formosa, from 4 June 1888 to 27 July 1889 during the absence of Consul Pelham Laird Warren who had taken Home Leave. Acting Consul Playfair also served as the Vice-Consul of the German Consulate in South Formosa, so when the German firm of Lauts & Haesloop had 55 boxes (about 15 and a half cwt.) of camphor seized from their agent in Lukang [鹿港] on 18 January 1889, Playfair was obliged to act. He did so efficiently and by 5 February 1889 was able to report to Sir John Walsham, the British Minister at Peking, and to Dr. Constantin Merz, the German Acting-Consul at Amoy [廈門], that the Tao-t’ai [道臺], or Circuit Intendant, had promised to release Lauts & Haesloop’s camphor and to refund any expenses. The timing was fortunate as the first British firm was on the point of re-entering the camphor trade when the seizure took place. Playfair identifies October, November and December as being the ‘dead season’ for commerce; and April, May and June, the sugar season, as being the active months. George Playfair also reports on the erection of a telegraph line between Tainan and Anping which would enable the Anping Consulate to become a complete alternative to the old Tainan Consulate. Finally, Playfair reports on the unsuccessful May 1889 visit of Liu Ming-ch’uan [劉銘傳] to the South, and attributes Liu’s dislike of Consul Warren to Warren’s ‘energetic action regarding Russell & Co’s compradore’.

      George Macdonald Home Playfair was born on 22 August 1850 at Shahjehanpore, Bengal, India, the son of George Ranken Playfair, the Surgeon-General of the Bengal Medical Service, and Frances Harriet Playfair née Home. The Playfair family was originally from St Andrews, Fife, and the University of St Andrews holds many family documents. George M. H. Playfair was educated at Cheltenham College, Gloucestershire, and Trinity College, Dublin. George Macdonald Home Playfair joined the China Consular Service as a Student Interpreter through the June 1872 Competitive Entrance Examinations for the China, Japan and Siam Consular Services, the first year of open competition. After his two years of studying Mandarin Chinese at the British Legation in Peking, Playfair was appointed acting Assistant Chinese Secretary in 1875. In 1876, George Macdonald Home Playfair was promoted to the rank of Third Assistant and appointed to the British Consulate at Taiwan [臺灣].

      George Macdonald Home Playfair was stationed as Third Assistant at the British Consulate on Formosa from 14 November 1876 through 1877. During 1877 Playfair served as Acting Consul from 21 February, when Acting Consul Thomas Watters departed to become Consul at Wuhu [蕪湖], to 18 April 1877, when Vice-Consul Alexander Frater arrived from Tamsui [淡水] to take charge. George Playfair departed to Foochow [福州] at the end of 1877.

      George M. H. Playfair was stationed at Foochow from the beginning of 1878, in which year he was promoted to Second Assistant, until the start of 1881, when he took Home Leave. George M. H. Playfair’s father, George Ranken Playfair, M.D., was seriously ill and died, aged 65, on 28 October 1881. George Ranken Playfair was living in a boarding house at 26 Longridge Road, Kensington, and his son was able to spend his last few months with him.

      Upon his return from England at the end of 1881, George Macdonald Home Playfair was stationed as Second Assistant at Pakhoi [北海], in the Gulf of Tonkin, on 15 December. Playfair remained at Pakhoi until 2 April 1883, spending much of 1882 and 1883 as acting Consul at Pakhoi. George Playfair was acting Consul on 23 August 1882, when Chinese Naval Forces bombarded Pakhoi in an endeavour to arrest a French Roman Catholic priest to whom acting Consul Playfair had given refuge. Chinese Imperial orders had been given to arrest all French subjects, as there was great tension between France and China over Tonkin, the northern part of Vietnam, that would eventually lead to the Sino–French War of August 1884 to April 1885 and the concurrent Blockade of Formosa.

      On 24 August 1883 George M. H. Playfair was posted as Second Assistant at Amoy [廈門]. A few months later, on 21 January 1884, George Macdonald Home Playfair married Winifred May Fraser, the daughter of John Fraser (deceased), Law Secretary and Registrar of the Supreme Court for China and Japan at Shanghai, and Elmira Jane Fraser née Werry, at St John’s Cathedral, Hongkong. Winifred May Fraser’s grandfather was Simon Fraser, the Commissioner of Delhi, from 1853 to 1857, prior to the Indian Mutiny. Their first child, a daughter named Dorothy Isabel Rose Playfair was born in December 1884 at Kulangsu, Amoy, and on 10 July 1885 the whole family of George, Winifred and the six-month old Dorothy Playfair left Amoy for Shanghai [上海], where George was acting Vice-Consul from 13 July 1885. Tragedy struck when Dorothy Isabel Rose Playfair, just one year old, died in January 1886. George and Winifred Playfair were given 3 weeks’ leave to visit Japan to recover from shock of losing their only child.

      George M. H. Playfair was promoted to First Assistant on 1 July 1886 during his prolonged absence. Upon his return to Shanghai Playfair served as First Assistant from 13 July to 22 December 1886, when he took Home Leave as Winifred May Playfair was pregnant again and wished to bear the child in England. Their second child, also a daughter, was christened Marjorie Playfair Playfair on 5 July 1887 at St Philip’s Church, Kensington, London. Upon his return alone to Shanghai in 1888 First Assistant Playfair was appointed to South Formosa.

      On his second appointment to Taiwan, First Assistant George Macdonald Home Playfair was stationed at Taiwan-fu as the Acting Consul of the Taiwan Consular District, or South Formosa, from 4 June 1888 to 27 July 1889. George Playfair served as Acting Consul during the absence of Consul Pelham Laird Warren who had taken Home Leave.

      Following the return of Consul Pelham Laird Warren to Formosa on 27 July 1889, George Macdonald Home Playfair was moved to the north of Formosa to serve as Acting Consul of the Tamsui [淡水] Consular District from 4 August 1889 to 27 February 1890 to reside at Tamsui.

      George Macdonald Home Playfair then served briefly at Chinkiang [鎮江] before being appointed Acting Vice-Consul in charge of shipping at Shanghai in 11 April 1890. G M H Playfair, who had been promoted to Vice-Consul on 1 April 1891, and to Senior Vice-Consul on 20 August 1892, remained at Shanghai until 15 June 1893, when he took Home Leave. During his Home Leave Playfair was promoted to Consul on 15 June 1893 posted to Ningpo [寧波] on 23 April 1894, though he did not take up the post until his return from Home Leave on 1 September 1894. Consul Playfair remained at Ningpo until 13 May 1899, although from 1 March 1899 he had served as officiating Consul at Swatow following the unexpected resignation of Consul Colin Mackenzie Ford on 1 March 1899 due to ill-health. On 13 May 1899 Playfair was appointed Consul at Foochow and, although he took Home Leave from 13 November 1900 to 6 April 1902 and had other absences, George Macdonald Home Playfair remained the Foochow Consul until his retirement at the age of 60 on 1 December 1910.

      George M H Playfair retired to live alone in the family home of 87 Victoria Street, Middlesex. Playfair wrote several books about China (see below). George Macdonald Home Playfair died 29 August 1917 at the Home Hospital, 16 Fitzroy Square, Middlesex.

      Apart from the fact that, according to Coates, George Playfair held a children’s Christmas Eve party at the Ningpo Consulate in the years following his 1894 Home Leave, there is no record of his wife, Winifred May Playfair, or daughter, Marjorie Playfair Playfair, ever coming to China after Marjorie’s birth in 1887. Nor, indeed, is there much evidence that they lived together during Playfair’s Home Leaves or after his retirement.

      His widow, Winifred May Playfair, a Christian Science Practitioner, and daughter, Marjorie Playfair Playfair, are recorded as living at 8 Cheltenham Terrace from 1911 until 1931, before moving to Imperial House, 151-154 Grosvenor Road, S.W.1. Winifred May Playfair died peacefully aged 77 on 7 April 1941 at Imperial House.

      George Macdonald Home Playfair’s sole child, Marjorie Playfair Playfair, moved after her mother’s death to 148 Marsham Court, Westminster, and died at Hawthorne House, a nursing home for Christian Scientists, Hampstead Heath, London N.W.3 aged 62 on 17 November 1949.

Some of the books that George Macdonald Home Playfair wrote, edited, or translated are:

The cities and towns of China : a geographical dictionary. By George Macdonald Home Playfair. 1st Edition with Foreword by Playfair, Foochow, 22 August 1879. 2nd Edition, published by Kelly and Walsh, Shanghai, 1910. (Revised Version of Edouard Constant Biot’s book of the same name published in French in 1842.)

The Chinese Government: A Manual of Chinese Titles, Categorically Arranged and Explained. Originally by William Frederick Mayers, revised by George Macdonald Home Playfair. Published by Kelly & Walsh, Shanghai, 1897.

An Anglo-Chinese Calendar for the years 1892-1911. By George Macdonald Home Playfair. Published by Kelly and Walsh, Shanghai, 1896. (gives corresponding Chinese and Gregorian calendars)

The best man comedietta in two scenes, with songs. By George Macdonald Home Playfair. Published by Kelly and Walsh, Shanghai, 1895.

Playfair also wrote various articles for publications such as The China Review. In particular China Review published his Notes on the language of the Formosa savage, in Volume VII, Number 5, (1879), pages 342-345.


Sources: Lo Hui-min and Bryant, Helen; British Diplomatic and Consular Establishments in China: 1793-1949, Volume II Consular Establishments 1843-1949; SMC Publishing Inc., Taipei, Taiwan, 1988.

The National Archives, British Foreign Office Files, series FO 228 (China).

Oakley, David Charles; The Story of the British Consulate at Takow; Privately published, Kaohsiung, Taiwan, 2007.

Coates, P. D.; The China Consuls: British Consular Officers, 1843-1943; Oxford University Press, 1988.

U.K. Probate Records; U.K. General Registry Office; The China Review.

British Consuls in South Formosa

George Macdonald Home Playfair

The Takao Club